Cadence (post: 1473817) wrote:I recently read Clover by CLAMP and quite enjoyed it. The story itself was nothing special, but the artwork was wonderful. I especially loved the panel layout. It gave the work a haunting and lonely but lovely quality.
Also, after nearly a year and a half, Amatsuki translations were finally updated. I am ecstatic. Toki is still an idiot, Bonten is still a selfish jerk, Susutake is hilarious, Kon is Kon, and Tsuyukusa is still a brat. The storytelling is every bit as hilariously "convenient" as ever. Normally this drives me crazy, but Takayama Shinobu makes it so blatantly obvious in Amatsuki that I just find it hilarious instead.
[
No, it hasn't been licensed and I would be really, really surprised if it ever was. It is a pretty niche title; English-speaking fandom for it is fairly small. Kind of a shame, since it is a lot of fun.airichan623 (post: 1473830) wrote:Has this 'Amatsuki' been licensed yet? I wanna read it now.
Atria35 (post: 1469822) wrote:Since I discovered my library has the missing volumes of Rozen Maiden I don't own, I've been determined to finish the series.
So far I've read v. 1-6
Definitely WAY different from the anime. I think it's a tad darker, but self-sacrifice always seems that way.
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1472676) wrote:So I forgot to mention that I read the first three volumes of Ranma 1/2 to see if it improves at all since the first couple chapters. It doesn't, and dropped.
Maokun (post: 1474553) wrote:I get it's quite different from the anime stylistically, but what about the plot? I'm kind of giving up the waiting for an anime conclusion but if the manga's story is going to differ so much that it's actually not going to continue the story as I know it, I'd rather not get invested.
Maokun (post: 1474579) wrote:Different enough that matters raised by the anime will not be addressed by the manga? I just want closure!
More especifically, [spoiler]the anime ended with the destruction of the fake Bara Suisho, but at the cost of starting the Alice Game for real, which meant that Hina Ichigo and Sousei Seki died, apparently for good. And then the real Bara Suisho appeared! Are those narrative threads continuated?[/Spoiler]
I found it to be really annoying and I guess I was just fed up with crappy romances involving tsunderes since I'd just finished Library Wars which set a pretty high bar for romances involving tsunderes. I found the characters annoying and got really tired of the plot, and I'm not going to check out a thirty-eight volume manga when the first three have me really disliking it.Maokun (post: 1474553) wrote:May I ask what did you not like of it? There's a chance that you'll like the anime, as I think it's one of the few cases where it is better than the parent manga (except for the fact that, uh, was unfinished.)
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1474627) wrote:I found it to be really annoying and I guess I was just fed up with crappy romances involving tsunderes since I'd just finished Library Wars which set a pretty high bar for romances involving tsunderes. I found the characters annoying and got really tired of the plot, and I'm not going to check out a thirty-eight volume manga when the first three have me really disliking it.
It's not that I think it's cliche or unoriginal, it's that I find it incredibly grating to see "Oh, they really love each other! But then a stupid gag happens and now they hate each other!" I don't think watching the original Rie Kugimiya tsundere show is going to make me like the character type anymore than I enjoy it in Hidan no Aria, just because it's really grating.Maokun (post: 1474707) wrote:The anime is, I think, better paced and past the introductory episodes, it becomes as much about fighting as it is a romantic comedy. If you find it tiringly unoriginal it's likely because it was one of the series (along with Kimagure Orange Road) to popularize -if not start- several of the tropes that are abused to death in the genre nowadays. Akane is for me, THE original Tsundere, way before the word came around and thankfully, before it meant "acting disturbingly several years older than the character's actual age."
Also, the friendship-rivalship between Ranma and Ryoga it's, in my opinion, one of the best out there.
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs wrote:It's not that I think it's cliche or unoriginal, it's that I find it incredibly grating to see "Oh, they really love each other! But then a stupid gag happens and now they hate each other!" I don't think watching the original Rie Kugimiya tsundere show is going to make me like the character type anymore than I enjoy it in Hidan no Aria, just because it's really grating.
Maokun wrote:I hardcore-marathoned Bleach to the latest available chapter. As expected, it is the lesser of the holy shounen triad of current manga (One Piece, Naruto, Bleach) but it still managed to be enjoyable, though I have to wonder why it continued at all after the epic Aizen arc. Also, it's arguably the easier on the eyes of all three.
Mr. Hat'n'Clogs (post: 1474710) wrote:It's not that I think it's cliche or unoriginal, it's that I find it incredibly grating to see "Oh, they really love each other! But then a stupid gag happens and now they hate each other!" I don't think watching the original Rie Kugimiya tsundere show is going to make me like the character type anymore than I enjoy it in Hidan no Aria, just because it's really grating.
Like I said, the night I dropped it I had just finished Library Wars which had a good romance involving a tsundere(who was a male, shockingly) but his tsundereness made sense and wasn't just a stupid gag to keep some unresolved romantic tension for thirty eight volumes.
uc pseudonym (post: 1474765) wrote:I finished Kurohime. It started a weak episodic format, got a strangely worthwhile large-scale plot, and ended up being disappointing. The ending actually wasn't all that impressive, despite featuring both the caption "4.6 billion years later" and the world being cut in half by a giant sword. Maybe romantic types like the reincarnation angle, but I found it an entirely unsatisfying conclusion.
I'm also a non-fan of Ranma 1/2, pretty much every aspect of it. Not that I have anything particular to say about it, so I guess that's just a statement of solidarity.
It goes against my nature to drop things, particularly something as brief a read as Bleach, but I came very close with this pointless new arc. I don't think there's anyone still believing anything at all is planned out, which kills one of the reasons I started reading Bleach. I very well might have stopped if not for Urahara's line implying the Spirit King was elemental (as opposed to another dozen characters who will never do much of anything).
Maokun wrote:This was rather spoilery, but I'm grateful. Now I know not to touch the thing with a mile long stick. I hate that kind of endings too.
Maokun wrote:Fully agreed. Only reason I'm hanging onto it is to see the explanation about Ichigo's dad stuff. Not that it's too hard to imagine, but I'll have my closure! I like to think that as make-up-as-we-go arc as the current one obviously is, the author actually has a proper, satisfactory and coherent ending fully planned for the story since the moment he started it.
All of the fun in Bleach for me in the most recent chapters come from a hilarious chapter summery/rip-off thing I came across on DA. It's worth skimming the 20 or so pages for each chapter and is the only reason I am still reading it.uc pseudonym (post: 1475545) wrote:I'm not sure how to feel about those plot issues. Part of the fun in Bleach lately has been seeing it destroy all the things that interested me in the beginning.
uc pseudonym (post: 1475545) wrote:Kubo Tite did say he had the most important scenes in mind but not details on connecting them. I used to think that he might just get sidetracked with long character-heavy arcs (Soul Society, Hueco Mundo) but with the way some things have gone I'm cynical. His brilliant plans for the ending may be something to the effect of: "Find 12 fetishes I haven't done yet and introduce characters for them. Everyone fights a bunch and Ichigo rescues captured female character. Note to self: they fight somewhere white-colored."
Return to Manga and Manga Reviews
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 29 guests